Ordering Several Clitics
Clitics have a conventional internal order rather than following English object order.
How It Works
The order
A Jezikovna svetovalnica answer gives the order of the cluster in the standard, and Greenberg's grammar has the same chart. The table lists the slots from left to right with the words that fill each one. Read it with one sentence: in Ana mu jo je dala, mu is slot 4, jo slot 5 and je slot 6.
| Slot | Words |
|---|---|
| 1 | the particle naj |
| 2 | biti forms with s-: sem, si, sva, sta, smo, ste, so; or bi |
| 3 | se, si (reflexive) |
| 4 | dative: mi, ti, mu, ji, nama, nam, vam, jim |
| 5 | accusative or genitive: me, te, ga, jo, je, nas, vas, jih |
| 6 | je, or bom, boš, bo, bova, bosta, bomo, boste, bodo |
| 7 | particles ne, že, še |
Why je moves
The two kinds of auxiliary sit in different slots. That is why the order changes when the person changes, as the same answer shows: Rekel mi je. (He told me.) but Rekli so mi. (They told me.) The table below walks one sentence, “gave it to him”, through four subjects.
| Subject | Cluster | Sentence |
|---|---|---|
| I (past) | sem mu ga | Dal sem mu ga. |
| she (past) | mu ga je | Dala mu ga je. |
| they (past) | so mu ga | Dali so mu ga. |
| I (future) | mu ga bom | Dal mu ga bom. |
The conditional bi sits with the s- forms, so it comes first: Rad bi ti jo pokazal. (I'd like to show it to you.) The reflexive comes before the other pronouns: Ali si se mu zahvalil? (Did you thank him?) and Ana se mu je nasmehnila. (Ana smiled at him.) The reflexive past is in Reflexive Past Forms With Je.
Dative before accusative
English says “give it to him”, with the thing first. Slovenian puts the person first: mu ga, ti jo, mi jih. The short pronouns themselves are taught in Short Dative Pronouns and Short Object Pronouns. Where the whole cluster stands in the clause is a separate question, answered in The Position of Unstressed Words.
Particles and negation
Že and še come right after the cluster: Ana mu ga je že dala. (Ana has already given it to him.) In the negative past, ne fuses with the auxiliary into nisem, nisi, ni, which Greenberg lists as required forms, so the pronouns come after the fused word: Nisem mu ga dal. (I didn't give it to him.) The negative future has its own entry, Negative Future Statements.
Examples (6)
- Včeraj sem mu jo dal.
Yesterday I gave it to him.
Sem comes before the pronouns, and the dative mu comes before the accusative jo.
- Ana mu jo je dala.
Ana gave it to him.
Third-person je goes after both pronouns, at the end of the cluster.
- Rad bi ti jo pokazal.
I would like to show it to you.
Bi sits in the first auxiliary slot, before ti and jo.
- Jutri ti ga bom prinesla.
I'll bring it to you tomorrow.
Bom goes after the pronouns, like je.
- Ana se mu je nasmehnila.
Ana smiled at him.
The reflexive se comes before the dative mu, and je closes the cluster.
- Rekli so mi, da bo zamudil.
They told me he would be late.
So belongs to the s- forms, so it comes before mi.
Common Mistakes
Accusative before dative
Dal sem ga mu.Dal sem mu ga.A Jezikovna svetovalnica answer gives the standard order as dative pronouns before accusative ones, so mu comes before ga.
Je before the pronouns
Ana je mu ga dala.Ana mu ga je dala.The same answer places je after the dative and accusative pronouns, unlike sem and so, which come before them.
Bom before the pronouns
Jutri bom ti ga dal.Jutri ti ga bom dal.In the standard order given by Jezikovna svetovalnica, forms beginning with bo- stand after the pronouns, in the same slot as je.
How It Connects
Learn This First
Locate the clitic cluster before ordering its dative, accusative and auxiliary members.
Related Patterns
- se jeReflexive Past Forms with Je
Se is in an earlier slot than je, so the reflexive past reads se je, and with a dative se mu je.
Level 5 - me, te, ga, joShort Object Pronouns
The accusative and genitive pronouns fill slot 5, after any dative pronoun and before je or bom.
Level 3 - bom / boš / bo + ParticipleThe Future Tense
Future auxiliaries take the last auxiliary slot: Dal ti ga bom. Their place differs from the past auxiliary sem.
Level 2 - bi + ParticipleThe Conditional
Bi takes the first auxiliary slot, so it comes before se and the pronouns: Rad bi se ji zahvalil.
Level 3