on (només per a llocs)

On Restricted to Places

Level 6

On introduces a relative clause whose antecedent is a place.

How It Works

Where on fits and where it does not

The IEC grammar (27.6.2) lists the cases where Catalan avoids on. The table walks the noun through each one; read the row for a scale with the word nota: Clara aims at a certain grade (aspirar a), so the relative keeps that a and agrees with the feminine noun, la nota a la qual aspira la Clara.

AntecedentRelativeExample
a physical placeon, en què, en el qualla sala on ens reunim
a place nameon onlyGirona, on viu la Laia
a timeen què, en el quall’any en què va néixer
a point on a scalepreposition + el qualla nota a la qual aspira la Clara
a figurative place or a documenten què, en el quall’article en què s’explica

On with no noun before it

The same section shows that on can work with no antecedent at all: Deixa-ho on era. It can also follow an adverb: allà on often has a general meaning, “wherever”, and arreu on or pertot on mean “everywhere that”. With an open place the verb usually goes in the subjunctive, as in Seieu allà on vulgueu; with a real one it stays in the indicative: Arreu on viatja, la Clara troba amics.

One preposition for two jobs

When the main clause and the relative clause need the same preposition, Catalan can say it once. The IEC grammar and the Optimot both give this: if you came down by a path and the relative also means “by which”, pel mateix corriol que vam pujar is correct, with plain que, as are per on and pel qual. When the two prepositions differ, both must appear, and the clause needs a noun to hang on: Torna-ho al lloc d’on ho has agafat, not a d’on.

The verb stays

English can say “I want to sit where you are” or even “where you do”, but the grammar notes that Catalan does not normally drop the verb of the on clause when it repeats the main verb: Vull seure on seus tu. For times, see also prepositional què, and for longer prepositions, el qual for clarity.

Examples (6)

  1. La sala on ens reunim és petita.

    The room where we meet is small.

    Sala is a physical place, the case where on fits best.

  2. L’any en què va néixer no consta.

    The year in which she was born is not recorded.

    A year is a time, not a place, so careful writing uses en què rather than on.

  3. És l’article en què s’explica el procediment.

    It is the article in which the procedure is explained.

    An article is a document, a figurative place, so en què is the clearer choice.

  4. Arreu on viatja, la Clara troba amics.

    Everywhere she travels, Clara makes friends.

    Arreu on means everywhere that; the indicative viatja describes real trips.

  5. Hem baixat pel mateix corriol que vam pujar.

    We came down the same path we went up.

    Both clauses need per, so one per is enough and the relative can be plain que.

  6. El preu al qual venen el pis és massa alt.

    The price at which they are selling the flat is too high.

    A point on a scale takes a preposition with el qual, not on: vendre a un preu gives al qual.

Common Mistakes

  • On for a point on a scale

    Un deu és la nota on aspira la Clara.
    Un deu és la nota a la qual aspira la Clara.

    The IEC grammar notes that on is not usual for a point on a scale. Keep the preposition the verb needs, a, and use la qual to agree with nota.

  • Two prepositions squeezed into one

    Torna-ho a d’on ho has agafat.
    Torna-ho al lloc d’on ho has agafat.

    The main verb needs a and the relative needs de. When the prepositions differ, both must appear, and the relative needs a noun such as lloc to follow.

  • Verb left out after on

    Vull seure on tu.
    Vull seure on seus tu.

    Catalan does not normally drop the verb of an on clause, even when it repeats the main verb, so the clause keeps seus.

How It Connects

Tap a pattern to see what it builds on and what it leads to.

on (només per a llocs)Level 6On Restricted to Places

Learn This First

Identify a locative antecedent before restricting on in formal prose. Keep the preposition licensed by the relative’s embedded function.

Words in This Pattern

Sources
  1. IEC, Gramàtica de la llengua catalana, 27.6.2: El relatiu locatiu
  2. Optimot, Relatiu locatiu: on, en què, en el qual (fitxa 7380)