Preposition Change before Infinitives
Some governed en or amb complements use a or de before an infinitive in careful formal writing.
How It Works
The rule
The GIEC (26.5.2) states that a and de stay before an infinitive, while en and amb alternate with a or de, often with either. Keeping en or amb is acceptable, and the change is preferable in formal registers. The table follows four verbs. Walk through insistir en: before a noun, Insisteix en el preu; before an infinitive, Insisteix a pagar.
| Verb | With a noun | With an infinitive (formal) |
|---|---|---|
| insistir en | Insisteix en el preu. | Insisteix a pagar. |
| pensar en (remember) | Pensa en les claus. | Pensa a agafar les claus. |
| estar d’acord amb | Estic d’acord amb el pla. | Estic d’acord a esperar. |
| conformar-se amb | Es conforma amb poc. | Es conforma a rebre una resposta. |
A or de?
For many verbs either works: the GIEC gives Comptava a, de or amb + infinitive, and the CPNL table shows Estic d’acord a/de and Pensa a/de venir. Some verbs prefer a even in everyday speech: afanyar-se, esforçar-se, tardar, trigar, ser el primer. So Hem trigat una hora a trobar aparcament is the natural form in formal and everyday Catalan alike.
Three meanings of pensar
The GIEC and the DIEC2 show that pensar changes meaning with its construction. With no preposition it means “to intend”: Pensem anar a València “We plan to go to Valencia.” With a (or en, de) + infinitive it means “to remember to” or “to have in mind”: Pensa a agafar el paraigua. With en + noun it means “to think about”: Penso en tu.
Before que, and where amb stays
If the complement is a clause with que, the preposition drops instead (see dropping prepositions before que): Insisteix en el preu, Insisteix a pagar, Insisteix que paguem. The DIEC2 entry for amb shows it staying before an infinitive in the idiom tenir a veure amb, which compares two things: Ser alt no té res a veure amb jugar bé. The Level 5 entry verbs governing en and amb lists more verbs.
Temporal en is different
The Universitat d’Alacant guide excludes en with a time meaning from the change. En arribar a casa “on arriving home” is a time expression, not a complement of a verb, so en stays (GIEC 31.4.2.1; see temporal en plus infinitive).
Examples (6)
- Pensa a tancar la finestra.
Remember to close the window.
Pensar a + infinitive means “remember to”; in formal writing a replaces the en used before a noun.
- Insisteix a pagar el compte.
He insists on paying the bill.
Insistir en becomes insistir a before the infinitive pagar.
- Es conforma a rebre una resposta.
She is content to receive an answer.
Conformar-se amb becomes conformar-se a before the infinitive rebre.
- Hem trigat una hora a trobar aparcament.
It took us an hour to find a parking space.
Trigar takes a before an infinitive, even in everyday speech.
- Pensem anar a València pel pont.
We plan to go to Valencia for the long weekend.
With no preposition, pensar + infinitive means “to intend”.
- En sortir de classe, la Núria va trucar a la seva mare.
On leaving class, Núria called her mother.
This en has a time meaning, so it does not change before the infinitive.
Common Mistakes
En before an infinitive, in formal writing
Insisteix en pagar el sopar.Insisteix a pagar el sopar.Before an infinitive the GIEC accepts en, but formal writing prefers a. Keep en before a noun: Insisteix en el preu.
Amb before an infinitive, in formal writing
Estem d’acord amb ajornar la reunió.Estem d’acord a ajornar la reunió.With an infinitive, amb is acceptable, but the GIEC and the CPNL prefer a or de in formal registers: estar d’acord a ajornar or estar d’acord d’ajornar.
Changing temporal en
A arribar a casa, em vaig dutxar.En arribar a casa, em vaig dutxar.En + infinitive with a time meaning is not a verb’s complement, so it keeps en. The change to a or de applies to complements such as insistir en.
How It Connects
Learn This First
Recognize lexical preposition government before replacing or dropping its complement marker. Recognize an infinitive and its own complements before changing prepositions or moving clitics.
Related Patterns
- Dropping Prepositions before Que
The companion rule for que clauses: the preposition drops instead of changing. Insisteix a pagar but Insisteix que paguem.
Level 4 - Verb + en/ambVerbs Governing En and Amb
That Level 5 entry lists verbs that take en or amb before a noun, the ones whose preposition can change before an infinitive.
Level 5 - Preposition Adjustment Before Infinitives
The Level 6 entry returns to the change in formal prose, with verbs such as tardar a and consistir a.
Level 6 - en + InfinitiveEn Plus Infinitive for Temporal Clauses
En arribar is a time expression meaning “on arriving”; it keeps en and is not part of this rule.
Level 5 - Preposition Change before Infinitives
The Level 5 entry practises the change with nouns and adjectives too, such as tinc interès a participar.
Level 5