Preposition Adjustment Before Infinitives

Level 6

Some governed en or amb complements use a or de before an infinitive in careful formal writing.

How It Works

Which en changes

The IEC grammar (26.5.2) says that a complement with en or amb alternates with a or de before an infinitive, that keeping en or amb is acceptable, and that the change is preferable in formal registers. That rule applies only to a complement the verb, noun or adjective asks for. One sentence can hold both kinds: En sortir de la reunió, l’Oriol va insistir a parlar-ne. The first en is the time word of temporal en + infinitive (“on leaving”) and stays; the second belongs to insistir, so formal writing turns it into a. A preposition that is part of a fixed phrase stays too: en lloc de “instead of” keeps en in En lloc de respondre el correu, va trucar.

One word at a time

Because the change follows the governing word, it is learned with that word. The table walks one complement, before a noun and before an infinitive, for four words. Take complaure’s: es complau en la feina ben feta, but es complau a ajudar els altres.

WordBefore a nounBefore an infinitive (formal)
insistiren la propostaa presentar-la
complaure’sen la feinaa ajudar
confiançaen el retorna or de tornar
estar d’acordamb el texta or de deixar-lo

The grammar names a group of predicates that take a before an infinitive even in informal speech: afanyar-se, esforçar-se, tardar, trigar, entretenir-se, ser el primer and ser l’últim. So Tarda a respondre and Sempre és la primera a arribar are the everyday forms, and the IEC dictionary’s examples for tardar use a throughout, so a is the form to expect after these words.

Pensar has three meanings

The grammar (26.5.2.2) separates them. Meaning “intend”, pensar takes a direct object, with an optional de: Penso (de) tornar-hi dilluns. Meaning “have your mind on”, it takes a or en: Només pensa a acabar. Meaning “remember to”, it takes a, en or de: Pensa a comprovar-ho abans de sortir. Choosing the preposition will not by itself tell the reader which meaning you want; the context does.

Where amb stays

The grammar keeps amb with predicates whose two sides could swap, such as tenir relació amb and tenir a veure amb. An amb of means can become de: L’amenaçaven d’expedientar-lo. Before a que clause the preposition is dropped altogether, as preposition loss before que explains.

Examples (6)

  1. Pensa a comprovar-ho abans de sortir.

    Remember to check it before leaving.

    Pensa a here means “remember to”, one of the three meanings of pensar, and it takes a before the infinitive comprovar-ho.

  2. Tarda a respondre.

    She takes a long time to reply.

    Tardar is one of the verbs that take a before an infinitive even in everyday speech, so tarda a respondre.

  3. Es complau a ajudar els altres.

    He takes pleasure in helping others.

    Complaure’s takes en before a noun, but formal writing prefers a before the infinitive ajudar.

  4. En sortir de la reunió, l’Oriol va insistir a parlar-ne.

    On leaving the meeting, Oriol insisted on talking about it.

    The first en is temporal and stays; the second complement belongs to insistir, so formal writing uses a.

  5. En lloc de respondre el correu, va trucar directament a la Clara.

    Instead of answering the email, he called Clara directly.

    En lloc de is a fixed phrase meaning “instead of”, so its en does not change before the infinitive.

  6. La Núria sempre és la primera a arribar a l’assaig.

    Núria is always the first to arrive at rehearsal.

    Ser el primer and ser l’últim usually take a before an infinitive, even in informal speech.

Common Mistakes

  • A before a noun

    L’Oriol va insistir a la darrera proposta del consell.
    L’Oriol va insistir en la darrera proposta del consell.

    The change from en or amb to a or de belongs to the infinitive. Before a noun, insistir keeps en, as the IEC grammar shows with insistir en els temes de sempre. Learners who have just learned the rule sometimes change the preposition everywhere.

  • Temporal en changed to a

    A arribar a l’estació, vam veure que el tren ja havia sortit.
    En arribar a l’estació, vam veure que el tren ja havia sortit.

    Here en + infinitive means “when we arrived”; it is not a complement of any verb, so the change to a does not apply. Formal writing keeps en arribar.

  • En changed inside a fixed phrase

    A lloc de trucar, li va escriure una carta.
    En lloc de trucar, li va escriure una carta.

    En lloc de is a fixed phrase meaning “instead of”, and the IEC dictionary lists it with en. The adjustment only touches a preposition that a verb, noun or adjective asks for.

How It Connects

Tap a pattern to see what it builds on and what it leads to.

Preposition Adjustment Before InfinitivesLevel 6

Learn This First

Preserve the lexical meaning when adjusting an infinitival preposition.

Sources
  1. IEC, Gramàtica de la llengua catalana, 26.5.2: L’alternança de preposicions àtones davant les subordinades substantives en infinitiu
  2. IEC, Gramàtica de la llengua catalana, 26.5.2.2: Alternança entre en, a i de
  3. IEC, Gramàtica de la llengua catalana, 26.5.2.3: Alternança entre amb, a i de
  4. Diccionari de la llengua catalana (DIEC2), tardar
  5. Diccionari de la llengua catalana (DIEC2), lloc (en lloc de)
  6. Diccionari de la llengua catalana (DIEC2), complaure