estar + Participle / ser + Participle
Resultant State Versus Passive Event
Ser plus participle presents a passive event; estar plus participle commonly presents a resulting state.
How It Works
Event and status in one report
Each construction answers a different question. The table walks aprovar and its neighbours through them. Compare the first two answers: va ser aprovada dimarts pel ple says what happened, when and by whom, and ara està aprovada says where things stand.
| Question | Construction | Example |
|---|---|---|
| What happened, when, by whom? | ser + participle | va ser aprovada dimarts pel ple |
| What is its status now? | estar + participle | ara està aprovada |
| What decides it? | estar or venir + participle + per | el preu està determinat per la demanda |
| What comes with it? | anar + participle + de | la inauguració anirà seguida d’un concert |
| How is someone regarded? | ser + participle + per or de | era molt respectada de tothom |
In every row the participle agrees with the subject, never with the agent: les sol·licituds van ser aprovades pel ple, la proposta va ser aprovada pel consell.
Between event and state
The IEC grammar (23.2.2) explains that with verbs such as determinar or establir a sentence with estar or venir describes a property, with a cause introduced by per, rather than an event. With verbs of order in space such as seguir, precedir or acompanyar, anar or venir + participle takes de: La ministra anava acompanyada de dos assessors. When the same verbs describe someone actually doing something, the sentence is a real passive and the doer takes per, as in the agent with per. With verbs of feeling or knowing, such as admirar, estimar or respectar, ser + participle describes a lasting state; the grammar notes that the complement can take de in formal registers, that the participle can take molt, and that it can be replaced by ho.
Regional and look-alike uses
The IEC grammar (22.3.1.3) records that several areas still use ser for the state with participles such as obert, tancat or fet, so El museu ja és obert is not a mistake. In Balearic and Girona speech, verbs of making take de for the maker in a sentence that describes a property: Aquest brodat és fet de la meva àvia. And some forms that look like participles are plain adjectives with no event behind them, such as deshabitat. The passive itself is built in the ser passive.
Examples (6)
- La porta va ser oberta pel conserge.
The door was opened by the caretaker.
Va ser oberta reports the opening as an event, and pel conserge names who did it.
- Ara la porta està oberta.
Now the door is open.
Està oberta describes the state of the door now, whoever opened it.
- Les sol·licituds estan aprovades.
The applications are approved.
Estan aprovades gives the status; aprovades agrees with les sol·licituds, feminine plural.
- Els contractes van ser signats el maig i ara estan registrats.
The contracts were signed in May and are now registered.
The dated event takes ser, and the current status takes estar; both participles agree with els contractes.
- La inauguració anirà seguida d’un concert.
The opening will be followed by a concert.
With anar and a verb of order such as seguir, the complement takes de, because nobody performs an action.
- La directora era molt respectada de tothom.
The director was greatly respected by everyone.
A participle of feeling describes a state here, so it takes molt and, in formal style, de.
Common Mistakes
Participle matched to the agent
La proposta va ser aprovat pel consell.La proposta va ser aprovada pel consell.The participle agrees with the subject, la proposta, which is feminine. The gender of the agent, el consell, plays no part.
Estar with a dated act
El contracte està signat ahir pel director.El contracte va ser signat ahir pel director.A dated act with a doer is an event, so it takes the ser passive. Estar describes the status now: ara el contracte està signat.
Per for an order in time
La inauguració anirà seguida per un concert.La inauguració anirà seguida d’un concert.With anar and a verb of order such as seguir, the IEC grammar gives de for what comes next, since no one performs an action. Per marks a doer in a true passive, as in va ser seguit per un individu sospitós.
How It Connects
Learn This First
Distinguish the passive event from the resulting participial state. Build a ser passive before contrasting its event with a resulting state.
Related Patterns
- per + AgentAgent Complement with Per
In a true passive the doer takes per, as in va ser aprovada pel ple.
Level 4 - estar + State/ResultEstar for State and Result
The Level 3 entry introduces estar for states and results with adjectives such as ple and cansat.
Level 3 - Absolute Participial Clauses
A participle can also open a sentence on its own, as in Aprovada la proposta, es va tancar la sessió.
Level 5