ne smem + Infinitive
Not Being Allowed to Do Something
Ne smem with an infinitive expresses lack of permission or a prohibition.
How It Works
How to build it
The verb is smeti, which has an -em present: smem, smeš, sme. Put ne in front and add an infinitive. The table walks vstopiti (enter) through the persons: ne smem vstopiti, ne smeva vstopiti, ne smejo vstopiti.
| Person | Singular | Dual | Plural |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | ne smem vstopiti | ne smeva vstopiti | ne smemo vstopiti |
| 2nd | ne smeš vstopiti | ne smeta vstopiti | ne smete vstopiti |
| 3rd | ne sme vstopiti | ne smeta vstopiti | ne smejo vstopiti |
The past uses the participle smel, smela: Ni smela ven. (She wasn't allowed out.) The future is ne bom smel: Jutri ne bom smel jesti.
What it means
SSKJ2 says that smeti with a negation expresses a prohibition, and also that something is unsuitable because of its bad results: Psa ne smete pustiti v avtu. (You mustn't leave the dog in the car.) Jezikovna svetovalnica explains that smeti assumes a rule or agreement: the action is possible, but the rule forbids it. Without ne, smem asks for or gives permission: Smem vstopiti? (May I come in?)
Mustn't, can't or don't have to
Compare three sentences. Ne smeš kaditi. means smoking is forbidden. Ne moreš kaditi. means smoking is impossible for you, which is ne morem + nedoločnik. Ni ti treba kaditi. means you don't need to smoke, which is ni treba + nedoločnik. In the standard, English “must not” is ne smeš, and a negated morati is replaced by ni treba: ne moraš, where it is heard, means “you don't have to”. A direct order can also use a negative imperative: Ne kadi! (Don't smoke!)
The object
The infinitive's object follows the negation into the genitive. SSKJ2 gives this rule for verbs like smeti, and Jezikovna svetovalnica confirms Ne smeš gledati televizije, not televizijo. So Jem torto. but Ne smem jesti torte. (I'm not allowed to eat cake.) See Direct Objects Under Negation.
On signs and in rules
Written rules often use the general ne sme or an impersonal sentence: V knjižnici se ne sme jesti. (Eating is not allowed in the library.) The impersonal se is taught in neosebni se.
Examples (6)
- Tukaj ne smem parkirati.
I am not allowed to park here.
Ne smem says a rule forbids parking; parkirati stays an infinitive.
- Ne smeš kaditi.
You must not smoke.
Ne smeš is the English “must not”; ne moraš would mean “you don't have to”.
- Otroci ne smejo vstopiti.
Children may not enter.
Smejo is the third-person plural, agreeing with otroci.
- Ne smem jesti torte.
I'm not allowed to eat cake.
Torte is genitive because jesti depends on the negated ne smem.
- Mama ni smela dolgo hoditi.
Mum wasn't allowed to walk for long.
The past uses the participle smela after the negated auxiliary ni.
- Smem odpreti okno?
May I open the window?
Without ne, smem asks for permission.
Common Mistakes
Ne moraš for “must not”
Ne moraš kaditi tukaj.Ne smeš kaditi tukaj.SSKJ2 gives smeti with a negation for a prohibition. Jezikovna svetovalnica notes that a negated morati is replaced by ni treba, so ne moraš would say smoking is unnecessary.
Accusative object after ne smem
Ne smeš gledati televizijo.Ne smeš gledati televizije.Jezikovna svetovalnica says Ne smeš gledati televizije is correct, because the bare object after the negated verb takes the genitive. SSKJ2 gives the same rule for infinitives after smeti.
How It Connects
Learn This First
Contrast necessity with lack of permission before translating English must not.
Related Patterns
- ne morem + InfinitiveBeing Unable to Do Something
Ne morem says an action is impossible; ne smem says it is not allowed.
Level 4 - ni treba + InfinitiveNot Having to Do Something
Ni treba says an action is unnecessary, which is the opposite of a prohibition: Ni ti treba priti versus Ne smeš priti.
Level 4 - Direct Instructions
A negative imperative such as Ne kadi! also forbids an action, speaking straight to the listener.
Level 3 - Direct Objects Under Negation
After ne smem, the infinitive's object takes the genitive: Ne smem jesti torte.
Level 4 - lahko + Present VerbAbility and Permission
Lahko can also give permission (Lahko greste), and ne smete takes it away.
Level 2
Words in This Pattern
Sources
- SSKJ2, Slovar slovenskega knjižnega jezika: smeti (with a negation, a prohibition)
- Jezikovna svetovalnica (ZRC SAZU language advice): Using moči and smeti
- Jezikovna svetovalnica (ZRC SAZU language advice): The genitive of negation (6), Ne smeš gledati televizije
- Jezikovna svetovalnica (ZRC SAZU language advice): The difference between moči and morati (ni morala replaced by ni treba)
- Slovenski pravopis 2001: smeti (smem, smel, smela)