Instrumental Without s
Tools and Transport
Croatian can name the means of an action with a bare instrumental noun. Pišem olovkom means I write with a pencil.
How It Works
How to build it
Take the noun for the tool or vehicle and give it its instrumental ending (see Instrumental Singular Endings). Most masculine nouns add -om, so vlak “train” becomes vlakom. A masculine noun that ends in a soft consonant usually adds -em, so nož “knife” becomes nožem. A feminine noun in -a changes -a to -om, so olovka “pencil” becomes olovkom. The table shows common tools and vehicles in this form.
| Thing | Instrumental | Sentence |
|---|---|---|
| olovka “pencil” | olovkom | Pišem olovkom. |
| nož “knife” | nožem | Režem kruh nožem. |
| žlica “spoon” | žlicom | Jedem juhu žlicom. |
| vlak “train” | vlakom | Putujem vlakom. |
| autobus “bus” | autobusom | Idem autobusom. |
| tramvaj “tram” | tramvajem | Vozim se tramvajem. |
Tool or company
English uses “with” for a tool and for a companion, and this is where learners slip. Ask whether the thing is something you use or someone who joins you. A pencil is used, so it takes the bare instrumental. A friend joins you, so it takes s: Pišem pismo s Ivanom. “I'm writing the letter with Ivan.” One sentence can hold both: Putujem vlakom s prijateljem. Vehicles follow the same rule: write vlakom, not s vlakom, because s marks company.
Walking and other ways
For going on foot, Croatian usually says pješice or pješke (adverbs), where English says “on foot”: Idem pješice. When the tool is unusual and you want to stress it, pomoću with the genitive means “by means of”: pomoću ključa. With a vehicle, the verb can be ići, putovati or voziti se; see Choosing a Movement Verb.
Where the rule stops
The bare instrumental is for tools and means. Some verbs take the instrumental for their own reasons and are learned with the verb, for example baviti se “be busy with”: Bavim se sportom. “I do sport.” And the instrumental noun can move around the sentence: after the object is the most neutral place (Režem kruh nožem.), while putting it first gives it weight.
Examples (6)
- Pišem olovkom.
I am writing with a pencil.
Olovkom is the instrumental of olovka and names the tool, with no preposition.
- Putujem vlakom.
I am travelling by train.
Vlakom names the means of travel; s is not used because the train is not a companion.
- Režem kruh nožem.
I am cutting bread with a knife.
Nožem has -em because nož ends in the soft consonant ž, and it comes after the object kruh.
- Putujem vlakom s prijateljem.
I am travelling by train with a friend.
Vlakom names the means and s prijateljem names the companion, so one sentence shows both uses.
- Maja ide na posao tramvajem.
Maja goes to work by tram.
Tramvajem has -em because tramvaj ends in the soft consonant j.
- Jedemo juhu žlicom.
We eat soup with a spoon.
Žlica is a feminine -a noun, so the tool takes -om: žlicom.
Common Mistakes
S with a vehicle
Putujem s autobusom.Putujem autobusom.The means of travel takes the instrumental with no preposition. S with the instrumental means travelling together with someone, which is why the Institute's advice corrects s vlakom to vlakom.
Tool left in the nominative
Režem kruh nož.Režem kruh nožem.The tool needs the instrumental ending: nož becomes nožem. Without an ending, nož reads as a subject or a plain noun, and the sentence is incomplete.
S with a tool
Pišem s olovkom.Pišem olovkom.A tool you write with takes the bare instrumental. With s, the pencil would sound like a companion sitting next to you.
How It Connects
Learn This First
The instrumental forms support the contrast between accompaniment and means.
Related Patterns
- s / sa + InstrumentalTogether with Someone
S with the instrumental adds a companion: Putujem s prijateljem. The bare instrumental names the tool or vehicle: Putujem vlakom.
Level 2 - Choosing a Movement Verb
With a vehicle in the instrumental, you choose ići, putovati or voziti se depending on what you want to say about the trip.
Level 1 - The Seven Cases
The instrumental is one of the seven cases. Besides the means, it marks company after s and the place after pod and nad.
Level 2