hindi ... kundi ang ...
Corrective Cleft
The hindi ... kundi ang ... pattern is a 'Corrective Cleft.' It is used to explicitly deny a statement and immediately provide the correct alternative. It translates to 'It is not [A], but rather [B].'
How It Works
How to build it. Start with an identifying sentence like those in the cleft: the rejected item comes first, then ang and the rest. Then add kundi and the correct item with its marker.
| Part | Example |
|---|---|
| hindi + rejected item | Hindi siya |
| ang + what is given | ang dumating, |
| kundi + ang/si + correct item | kundi ang kapatid niya. |
Use si for a personal name on either side: Hindi si Ana ang nagluto, kundi si Ben. The correct item can be any noun phrase, including an action noun such as pagsisinungaling (lying), made with pag-.
Without ang. When the correction is a description or an action, not an identity, leave out ang and use the basic hindi ... kundi ..., as in Hindi siya pagod kundi gutom (He is not tired but hungry).
Short words after hindi. Particles such as ba and po, and short pronouns such as ka and ko, usually form a cluster right after hindi, in their normal order (see second position). The order inside the cluster varies: Hindi ka ba, but Hindi ba siya. A pronoun that is itself the rejected person, as in Hindi siya ang dumating, is the item being identified, not a short word in the cluster; the entry hindi ako ang ... covers that shape.
Kundi and kung hindi. Kundi comes from kung hindi, but in this pattern it is written as one word. Written out, kung hindi (or kung di) means if not. After a negative, kundi can also mean except: Walang ibang paraan kundi ito.
Choosing a neighbour. Hindi lamang ... kundi pati adds the second item (not only, but also); this pattern replaces the first item. The pattern is used in both speech and writing.
Examples (5)
- Hindi pula ang gusto ko, kundi ang asul.
It's not the red one I want, but rather the blue one.
Word by Word: Not red the want I, but-rather the blue.
The rejected choice, red, comes first. Kundi ang names the right choice, blue.
- Hindi siya ang dumating, kundi ang kapatid niya.
It wasn't him who arrived, but rather his sibling.
Word by Word: Not he the arrived, but-rather the sibling of-him.
Here siya is the person identified and rejected, not a short pronoun in the cluster. Kundi ang names the person who did arrive.
- Hindi ang presyo ang inaalala ko, kundi ang kalidad.
It's not the price I'm worried about, but rather the quality.
Word by Word: not the price the being-worried-about by-me, but the quality
Both sides are ang phrases, so the sentence contrasts two concerns: the price is set aside and the quality is what matters.
- Hindi ang pera ang naging problema, kundi ang iyong pagsisinungaling.
It wasn't the money that was the problem, but rather your lying.
Word by Word: Not the money the became problem, but-rather the your lying.
The correct item, ang iyong pagsisinungaling, is an ang phrase with the action noun pagsisinungaling.
- Hindi ito biro, kundi ang katotohanan.
This is not a joke, but rather the truth.
Word by Word: Not this joke, but-rather the truth.
Kundi ang katotohanan identifies what the thing really is. Without ang, the phrase kundi katotohanan would describe it instead.
Common Mistakes
Writing kung hindi for kundi
Hindi asul ang gusto ko kung hindi ang pula.Hindi asul ang gusto ko kundi ang pula.In standard spelling, written out, kung hindi means if not and starts a condition. In this pattern, write the single word kundi.
Dropping si before a name
Hindi si Ana ang nagluto, kundi Ben.Hindi si Ana ang nagluto, kundi si Ben.The correct item needs its marker too. A personal name takes si, just like the rejected name.
Using it to mean not only
Hindi lamang ang kape ang gusto ko, kundi ang tsaa.Hindi lamang ang kape ang gusto ko, kundi pati ang tsaa.When you want both items, add pati after kundi. Without it, kundi ang replaces the first item instead of adding to it.
How It Connects
Learn This First
The 'hindi ... kundi ang ...' pattern is a corrective cleft used to reject one premise and replace it with a focused noun or clause. To learn this, learners must first understand basic contrastive negation (hindi... kundi), how to form headless relative clauses using 'ang', and the general structure of negative cleft sentences.
Related Patterns
- ang ... ayFocused Identification
The first half of this pattern is an identifying sentence. This entry explains how such sentences pick out who or what.
Level 4 - hindi lamang ... kundi patiNot Only ... but Also
Hindi lamang ... kundi pati adds a second item. Hindi ... kundi ang replaces the first item.
Level 3 - kung hindiUnless / if Not
Kung hindi means if not or otherwise. In the corrective pattern, the single word kundi is used.
Level 4 - Second-Position Words
Short particles and pronouns cluster after hindi. This entry explains their order.
Foundations