Past or Present Perfect
Use the simple past for a finished time, and har with a participle when no finished time is named.
How It Works
Both forms talk about the past. The choice depends on whether you name a time that is finished.
| Simple past (finished time) | Present perfect (open time) |
|---|---|
| Eg var i Bergen i går. | Eg har vore i Bergen. |
| Vi åt klokka fem. | Vi har ete. |
| Ho flytta hit i 2020. | Ho har budd her sidan 2020. |
A good test: if the sentence names a time that is over, use the past. If the point is that it has happened at all, or that it still goes on, use har.
A conversation often starts with har and moves to the past once a time is fixed: Har du sett filmen? Ja, eg såg han i helga.
A time that is not yet over, such as i dag or i år, can take har: Eg har jobba mykje i dag.
Examples (5)
- Eg var i Bergen i går.
I was in Bergen yesterday.
I går is a finished time, so the verb is in the past.
- Eg har vore i Bergen mange gonger.
I have been to Bergen many times.
No finished time is named, so har is used.
- Har du sett filmen? Ja, eg såg han i helga.
Have you seen the film? Yes, I saw it at the weekend.
The question uses har, and the answer with a time uses the past.
- Ho flytta til Førde i 2020.
She moved to Førde in 2020.
A year in the past takes the simple past.
- Vi har ikkje ete enno.
We have not eaten yet.
Enno goes with har.
Common Mistakes
Using har with a finished time.
Eg har vore i Bergen i fjor.Eg var i Bergen i fjor.I fjor is a finished time, so use the simple past.
How It Connects
Learn This First
Choosing between the two needs both tenses and time words for a finished time.
- har + Past ParticiplePresent Perfect
Know the present perfect, since this entry sets it against the past.
Level 2 - Common Irregular Past Forms
Know common past forms like var, since the example compares Eg var i Bergen with Eg har vore i Bergen.
Level 2 - i dag/i morgon/i gårToday, Tomorrow and Yesterday
Know time words like i går, since a finished time like that calls for the past.
Level 1