Deeply Nested Relative Clauses (Schachtelsatz)

Level 6

The Schachtelsatz (box sentence) is a hallmark of formal German. It involves inserting a relative clause into the middle of another clause, often separating the subject from its verb. This creates a high cognitive load but allows for extreme precision.

How It Works

In advanced German, particularly in legal or academic contexts, writers use nested subordination to maintain logical density.

1. The Sentence Bracket (Satzklammer):
This pattern relies on the sentence bracket. Because a German relative clause normally pushes its verb to the end, a nested relative clause forces the reader to hold one unfinished clause in memory while a second clause runs its full course. Read this two-level example: Der Vertrag, den der Anwalt, der das Unternehmen vertritt, aufgesetzt hat, ist bindend. ('The contract that the lawyer who represents the company drew up is binding.') The outer clause opens with Der Vertrag and does not reach its verb ist until after both relative clauses, just before bindend. Inside it, den der Anwalt … aufgesetzt hat is itself interrupted by a second relative clause, der das Unternehmen vertritt.

To decode a Schachtelsatz, match every relative pronoun to the verb that closes its own box, working from the inside out: vertritt closes the innermost box, aufgesetzt hat closes the middle one, and ist bindend completes the main clause. The boxes must be closed in the reverse of the order they were opened. If an inner clause happens to end in a double infinitive, its conjugated verb moves in front of that infinitive pair instead of standing last, which shifts where that box closes.

German also allows — and in practice often prefers — Extraposition (Ausklammerung), which lifts an embedded clause out into the Nachfeld (after the final verb) so the brackets never stack up: Der Vertrag ist bindend, den der Anwalt aufgesetzt hat, der das Unternehmen vertritt. ('The contract is binding that the lawyer drew up who represents the company.')

2. Morphological Rules:
The relative pronoun must match its antecedent in gender and number, but its case is determined by its role in its own specific 'box'. If a relative clause with a preposition is used, the relative pronoun is usually the object of that preposition, but it can also be a genitive inside the prepositional phrase (der Freund, mit dessen Hilfe), and the phrase as a whole functions as an adverbial or prepositional object. For English speakers, it is vital to note that prepositions cannot be stranded at the end of the clause; the preposition must immediately precede the relative pronoun. Furthermore, when the antecedent is an indefinite pronoun (e.g., alles, nichts) or an entire clause, German commonly uses a wo-compound (e.g., worüber) instead of a preposition plus relative pronoun, although the preposition plus pronoun also occurs there. To avoid repetitive sounds (like das, das...), writers often make the stylistic choice to switch to welcher/welche/welches for one of the layers. Note that relative welcher has no masculine or neuter genitive form, so the genitive relative pronoun dessen is needed there. A feminine or plural genitive welcher exists, but deren is usually preferred.

3. Punctuation:
Every relative clause inserted inside another clause needs a comma on both sides. When the clause ends the sentence, the period takes the place of the closing comma. Missing a closing comma is a common error that breaks the logic of the nesting.

4. Register and Readability:
This is rarely spoken. In spoken German, speakers avoid these structures through Extraposition (Ausklammerung), moving clauses outside the bracket. It is a stylistic tool for Bildungssprache (educated language) and formal documentation. While two levels of nesting are common in formal German, learners should be aware that exceeding this can create Schachtelsatz-Ungetüme (sentence monsters) that severely impede readability even for native speakers. Additionally, in formal and academic contexts, writers frequently avoid the logical density of multiply embedded relative clauses by using an extended participial attribute (e.g., die von mir ihm gegebene Akte) as a left-branching modifier.

Examples (3)

  1. Der Mann, der den Hund, der gestern weggelaufen war, gefunden hat, bekommt eine Belohnung.

    The man who found the dog that had run away yesterday is receiving a reward.

    Word by Word: The man, who the dog, which yesterday run away was, found has, receives a reward.

    A classic double nest. The main clause 'Der Mann bekommt eine Belohnung' is split by two relative clauses. Note the three verbs at the end of the nested section.

  2. Die Anträge, welche von Personen, die das achtzehnte Lebensjahr noch nicht vollendet haben, eingereicht wurden, sind ungültig.

    The applications which were submitted by persons who have not yet completed their eighteenth year are invalid.

    Word by Word: The applications, which by persons, who the eighteenth life-year yet not completed have, submitted were, are invalid.

    This uses 'welche' to avoid repeating 'die'. It is typical of administrative German.

  3. Das Haus, das mein Großvater, der ein bekannter Architekt war, selbst gebaut hatte, wurde gestern verkauft.

    The house, which my grandfather, who was a famous architect, had built himself, was sold yesterday.

    Word by Word: The house, that my grandfather, who a known architect was, self built had, was yesterday sold.

    The inner clause (about the architect) is nested inside the clause about the grandfather building the house, which is nested in the main clause about the sale.

Common Mistakes

  • Forgetting the closing comma of an internal nest.

    Der Autor, der das Buch, das ich lese geschrieben hat ist berühmt.
    Der Autor, der das Buch, das ich lese, geschrieben hat, ist berühmt.

    In German, a subordinate clause inserted inside another clause needs a comma on both sides. Without the comma after lese and the one after hat, the sentence structure collapses.

  • Incorrect verb placement in the 'stack'.

    Der Mann, der den Hund, der weggelaufen war, hat gefunden, ist hier.
    Der Mann, der den Hund, der weggelaufen war, gefunden hat, ist hier.

    In a relative clause, the conjugated verb normally comes last; the exception is haben before a double infinitive with a modal verb. When nesting, this often results in a 'verb stack' at the end of the nested section.

How It Connects

Tap a pattern to see what it builds on and what it leads to.

Deeply Nested Relative Clauses (Schachtelsatz)Level 6

Learn This First

To learn deeply nested relative clauses (Schachtelsätze), a learner must first be comfortable with the basic mechanics of German relative clauses and the verb-final word order they require. Additionally, a strong grasp of the German sentence bracket (Satzklammer) is necessary to track the main clause's meaning when it is interrupted by multiple layers of sub-clauses.

Sources
  1. Erweiterung von Nominalphrasen mit Attributsätzen
  2. Relativsätze im Deutschen und im Italienischen. Ein Vergleich unter Berücksichtigung von Nicht-Standard-Varietäten
  3. satzinterne Gliederungszeichen
  4. Stellungsfelder und Satzklammer