Multiple Embedded Subordinate Clauses
Multiple nested subordinate clauses (a form of Hypotaxe) involve placing one dependent clause inside another. This creates a hierarchical structure where you must finish the inner thought before completing the outer one.
How It Works
Advanced German writing, particularly in academic, legal, and literary contexts, utilizes complex embedding to show precise logical relationships.
1. The 'Russian Doll' Structure:
A sentence starts with a main clause, but before the main verb appears, a subordinate clause is inserted. That subordinate clause might itself be interrupted by another clause (like a relative clause).
2. Verb Stacking:
Because German uses Verb-Final order for most subordinate clauses, center embedding can place several verbs close together near the end. Each inner clause ends with its own verb before the clause around it continues, so in a fully nested sentence the verb of the innermost clause usually comes first. When a subordinate clause is moved to the end of its containing clause instead (into the Nachfeld), the verbs do not stack this way.
3. Punctuation Rules:
German uses commas to separate each subordinate clause from the clause that contains it. If a clause is embedded in the middle of another, it needs a comma at both its start and its end. Two subordinate clauses of equal rank joined by und or oder are normally not separated by a comma.
4. Stylistic Limits:
While this structure demonstrates a high level of proficiency, embedding more than three levels deep is generally avoided as it becomes difficult for the reader to track the original subject.
Examples (3)
- Der Brief, den er, nachdem er lange gezögert hatte, endlich schrieb, blieb unbeantwortet.
The letter, which he, after he had hesitated for a long time, finally wrote, remained unanswered.
Word by Word: The letter, which he, after he long hesitated had, finally wrote, remained unanswered.
Here, the relative clause 'den er... schrieb' is interrupted by the temporal clause 'nachdem er... hatte'. Note the comma placement: 'hatte' ends the inner clause and 'schrieb' ends the relative clause.
- Es ist wichtig, dass die Ergebnisse, obwohl sie vorläufig sind, da sie auf einer kleinen Stichprobe basieren, dennoch veröffentlicht werden.
It is important that the results, although they are preliminary, since they are based on a small sample, are nevertheless published.
Word by Word: It is important, that the results, although they preliminary are, since they on a small sample base, nevertheless published become.
This shows three levels: 1. 'dass' clause, 2. 'obwohl' clause, 3. 'da' clause. Each must be resolved before returning to the previous level.
- Der Junge, dem ich das Fahrrad, das mein Opa repariert hatte, geliehen habe, hat sich sehr gefreut.
The boy to whom I lent the bike that my grandpa had repaired was very happy.
Word by Word: The boy, to-whom I the bike, that my grandpa repaired had, lent have, has himself very rejoiced.
This uses nested relative clauses. The innermost clause das mein Opa repariert hatte is completed before the outer relative clause dem ich das Fahrrad geliehen habe finishes.
Common Mistakes
Forgetting the closing comma of an embedded clause.
Der Mann, der dort steht ist mein Vater.Der Mann, der dort steht, ist mein Vater.In German, a subordinate clause inserted into the middle of another clause normally needs both an opening and a closing comma. English speakers often forget the second comma before the main verb.
Misplacing the verb of the outer clause.
Dass er, weil er krank war, konnte nicht kommen, ist schade.Dass er, weil er krank war, nicht kommen konnte, ist schade.The verb of the 'dass' clause (konnte) must come after the entire 'weil' clause is finished, following the verb-final rule for subordinate clauses.
How It Connects
Learn This First
To learn complex embedding, you must first be comfortable with the verb-final word order of single subordinate and relative clauses. You also need to understand the concept of the 'sentence bracket' (Satzklammer), as nesting multiple clauses creates a series of brackets that must be closed in the correct order.
- Relative Clause Word Order
Relative clauses are one of the most common types of clauses nested within other clauses in complex German sentences.
Level 3 - Sentence Bracket (Satzklammer)
Understanding the 'sentence bracket' is essential for managing multiple verbs accumulating at the end of nested structures.
Level 4
Related Patterns
- Verb-Final In Subordinate Clauses
This is the usual pattern for clauses introduced by subordinators such as dass or weil, which put the verb at the end. Some other kinds of subordinate clause, such as reported speech without dass, keep the verb in second position.
Level 2 - weilBecause (Weil)
A common subordinator used to create causal layers within complex sentences.
Level 2 - obwohlAlthough (Obwohl)
Often used in academic writing to add concessive layers to a nested structure.
Level 3 - Double Infinitive Construction
Complex verb clusters at the end of nested clauses often involve double infinitive constructions.
Level 3
Learn Next
Patterns that build on this one.