〜はともかく
Setting Aside
Use 〜はともかく when you want to say 'Setting [A] aside for now...' or 'Regardless of [A]...' to focus on a more important point [B].
How It Works
How to build it
Put a noun before はともかく, with no だ. Take 味 (taste): 味 → 味はともかく. A verb or adjective first becomes a question with かどうか or a question word, or a noun phrase with の. Take 勝てる (can win): 勝てる → 勝てるかどうか → 勝てるかどうかはともかく. The table below shows the shapes.
| Before it | Example |
|---|---|
| Noun | 給料はともかく |
| Yes-or-no question | 勝てるかどうかはともかく |
| Question word | いつ行くかはともかく |
| Verb + の | 読むのはともかく |
| Particle phrase | 外ではともかく |
Adding として, as in 給料はともかくとして, sounds slightly more formal.
What comes next
The second half can be good or bad news: 景色はともかく、道はとても大変だった. It can also be an intention, an invitation or a request: 結果はともかく、全力でやろう. Often the point set aside is a weak spot, such as looks, taste or pay, but that is not required.
ともかく on its own
Without a noun and は, ともかく is an adverb meaning at any rate: ともかく行ってみよう.
はともかく or は別として?
は別として is almost the same and can also exclude one case from a general statement. はさておき is often used to move on to the main topic: 冗談はさておき、本題に入りましょう.
Not the same as はもちろん
はもちろん includes the first item as obvious: 歌はもちろん、ダンスも上手だ means he is good at both. はともかく leaves the first item out of the judgment.
Register
はともかく is standard Japanese and works in conversation and writing.
In reviews
Reviews often use it to put a weak point to one side before the main verdict: 値段はともかく、サービスは一流だ, price aside, the service is first-rate. A speaker can also use it to stop a side argument and move on: 細かいことはともかく、まず始めよう.
Examples (4)
- デザインはともかく、この靴はとても履き心地がいい。
Setting the design aside, these shoes are very comfortable to wear.
Word by Word: Design (topic) aside, these shoes (topic) very wearing-feeling good.
The speaker acknowledges the design might not be great, but emphasizes the comfort.
- 勝てるかどうかはともかく、精一杯やってみよう。
Whether we can win or not aside, let's give it our all.
Word by Word: Can win whether-or-not (topic) aside, with all one's might let's try doing.
Here, the result (winning) is treated as secondary to the effort being put in.
- 今の仕事は、給料はともかくとして、やりがいがある。
Setting aside the salary, my current job is rewarding.
Word by Word: Current job (topic), salary (topic) aside, worth-doing exists.
The speaker uses the more formal '〜はともかくとして' to prioritize job satisfaction over pay.
- 味はともかく、見た目はとてもきれいな料理だ。
Setting aside the taste, the appearance of this dish is very beautiful.
Word by Word: Taste (topic) aside, appearance (topic) very beautiful dish is.
This implies the taste might not be good, but the visual presentation is excellent.
Common Mistakes
Attaching the pattern directly to a dictionary form verb without nominalization.
食べるはともかく、料理を作るのは好きだ。食べるのはともかく、料理を作るのは好きだ。〜はともかく follows a noun. A verb or adjective first becomes a noun phrase with の, or a question with かどうか: 食べるのはともかく, 勝てるかどうかはともかく.
Confusing it with 'Not only... but also'.
彼は歌はともかく、ダンスも上手だ。彼は歌はもちろん、ダンスも上手だ。〜はともかく implies the first item is being ignored or is less important. If you want to say he is good at both, use 〜はもちろん.
How It Connects
Learn This First
〜はともかく (wa tomokaku) is used to set aside one issue or quality to focus on a more important one. To understand it, you need to be comfortable with the topic marker 'は' and how to structure sentences where one point is contrasted with or prioritized over another.
Related Patterns
- 〜はさておきLeaving Aside
Very similar, but '〜はさておき' is the usual choice for moving on to the main topic, as in 冗談はさておき, while '〜はともかく' sets one point aside to judge another.
Level 4 - を問わずRegardless of
を問わず says that something holds across every case, such as every age. 〜はともかく sets one point aside so the speaker can talk about another.
Level 3 - 〜ならいざしらずPerhaps...but
Used for extreme or hypothetical cases where the current situation is considered unacceptable, unlike the more neutral '〜はともかく'.
Level 5 - かどうかWhether or Not
Often used together with '〜はともかく' to nominalize a verb phrase into 'whether or not [verb] is the case'.
Level 2 - はもちろんNot to Mention
While '〜はともかく' sets something aside as less important, '〜はもちろん' emphasizes that the first item is definitely included/true.
Level 3
Learn Next
Patterns that build on this one.