Nested institutional passives
Formal institutional prose can combine modals such as harus and dapat with passive verbs to state requirements and possibilities. An agent can remain unexpressed or appear in an oleh phrase.
How It Works
How a chain is built. Each layer adds one idea, and the usual order follows the meaning, from widest to narrowest.
| Layer | Common words | Example chain |
|---|---|---|
| duty or need | harus (must), wajib (obliged) or perlu (need) | harus ... |
| expectation (often instead of the duty word) | diharapkan | diharapkan dapat ... |
| ability | dapat or bisa (can) | harus dapat ... |
| aspect or manner | sudah (already) or segera (soon) | harus sudah dapat ... |
| passive verb | di- verbs, often with -kan or -i | harus sudah dapat diverifikasi |
Take the chain harus dapat diperbaiki. The word harus covers everything after it, so the requirement is that repair must be possible. This is why the duty word comes before the ability word. Each layer also has its own entry: harus di- for duty, dapat di- for ability and perlu di- for need. Keep the suffix that the active verb has: menyerahkan becomes diserahkan, and menindaklanjuti becomes ditindaklanjuti.
Who acts. Most chains leave the actor out, which is the point of the agentless institutional style. When the actor is a noun, it can follow the verb with oleh, or directly if nothing comes between them, as passive agent without oleh shows: ditandatangani kepala dinas (signed by the head of the office). If other words come between the verb and the actor, use oleh. When the actor is saya (I), kami (we) or kita (we), standard writing usually switches to object voice. The modal words stay in front, the pronoun comes next, and the bare verb follows: harus dapat kami selesaikan.
Register and plain alternatives. These chains sound official and careful, and they let a writer state a rule without naming the person responsible. Some writing guides on bahasa birokrasi (bureaucratic language) point out that long chains are wordy and hide who must act, a concern that nominalization and hidden agency discusses. In conversation, and in clear plain writing, people say the same thing actively: Kami harus bisa menyelesaikan masalah ini (We have to be able to solve this problem).
Examples (6)
- Laporan keuangan tersebut harus dapat dipertanggungjawabkan secara transparan.
The financial report must be able to be accounted for transparently.
Word by Word: Report finance that must can be-accounted-for in-a-way transparent.
The chain harus dapat with the verb dipertanggungjawabkan makes accountability itself the requirement, without naming who answers.
- Hasil evaluasi ini perlu segera ditindaklanjuti oleh pihak terkait.
The results of this evaluation need to be immediately followed up on by the relevant parties.
Word by Word: Result evaluation this need immediately be-followed-up-on by party related.
Perlu and segera come before the verb, and the actor appears at the end with oleh.
- Kebijakan baru tersebut diharapkan dapat diselesaikan sebelum akhir tahun anggaran.
The new policy is expected to be able to be completed before the end of the fiscal year.
Word by Word: Policy new that be-expected can be-completed before end year budget.
The passive diharapkan is the first layer, followed by dapat and the main passive verb.
- Data penelitian ini harus sudah dapat diverifikasi sebelum dipublikasikan.
This research data must already be able to be verified before being published.
Word by Word: Data research this must already can be-verified before be-published.
Sudah sits between harus and dapat and sets a deadline: by publication time.
- Target penjualan ini harus dapat kami capai pada akhir tahun.
We must be able to reach this sales target by the end of the year.
Word by Word: Target sale this must can we reach at end year.
With a first-person actor, the chain uses object voice: modals first, then kami, then the bare verb capai.
- Usulan tersebut perlu dikaji lebih lanjut oleh tim ahli sebelum disetujui.
The proposal needs to be studied further by a team of experts before it is approved.
Word by Word: Proposal that need be-studied more further by team expert before be-approved.
Lebih lanjut comes between the verb and the actor, so oleh is needed.
Common Mistakes
Putting kami after the di- verb
Masalah ini harus dapat diselesaikan kami.Masalah ini harus dapat kami selesaikan.With a first-person actor, standard Indonesian uses object voice: the pronoun comes before a bare verb without di-. Learners copy the noun-actor pattern, as in diselesaikan panitia, onto pronouns.
Putting the modal after the pronoun
Masalah ini kami harus selesaikan.Masalah ini harus kami selesaikan.In object voice, modal and aspect words come before the actor pronoun. The pronoun and the bare verb stay together as one unit.
Dropping the -kan of the verb
Laporan itu harus segera diserah kepada atasan.Laporan itu harus segera diserahkan kepada atasan.A passive keeps the suffix that the active verb has, so menyerahkan becomes diserahkan. Without -kan, the form is not standard Indonesian.
How It Connects
Learn This First
To understand nested institutional passives, a learner must first be comfortable with basic passive constructions (di-) and how they interact with suffixes like -kan. Additionally, they need to understand how modal verbs (harus, dapat, perlu) function as auxiliary elements that precede the verb to create layers of obligation or possibility.
- harus + VerbObligation with Harus
Modal verbs like 'harus' or 'dapat' are the initial layers in these bureaucratic chains, providing the scope for the passive action.
Level 1 - di-...-kanPassive Causative or Benefactive
Bureaucratic prose frequently uses complex derived verbs (causative/benefactive passives) as the base of the chain.
Level 4
Related Patterns
- harus di-Required Passive Action
Harus plus a di- verb is the simplest form of a requirement. A chain adds more layers, such as dapat or sudah, in front of the verb.
Level 5 - dapat di-Formal Possibility Passive
Dapat plus a di- verb says that something can be done. In a chain, it follows the duty word, as in harus dapat dilaksanakan.
Level 5 - Agentless passive in formal prose
That entry covers the wider habit of leaving the institution out of a passive. Passive chains are one of its most common forms.
Level 5 - Object voice with saya or aku
When the actor is saya (I), kami (we) or kita (we), a chain switches to object voice, as in harus dapat kami selesaikan.
Level 3 - Adjacent passive agent
A short noun actor can follow the verb directly. If other words come between them, oleh is needed.
Level 3 - dipertanggungjawabkanPassive Accountability Form
Dipertanggungjawabkan is one of the most frequent verbs at the end of a chain, as in harus dapat dipertanggungjawabkan.
Level 5