上(じょう)
From the Standpoint of
The suffix 上 (じょう) is used in formal Japanese to restrict the scope of a statement to a specific field, such as law, health, or theory. It translates to 'legally,' 'theoretically,' or 'from the perspective of...'
How It Works
How to build it
Put 上 straight after a noun, with no の in between. Take 法律 (law): 法律 → 法律上(ほうりつじょう). Before another noun, add の: 仕事上の付き合い, a work relationship, or 歴史上の人物, a historical figure. Particles can follow it, and the reading stays じょう: 法律上は, データ上で, 地図上では. The table below shows common words.
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 法律上 | legally, under the law |
| 理論上 | in theory |
| 健康上 | for health reasons, health-wise |
| 仕事上 | for work, in a work context |
| 立場上 | because of one's position |
| 歴史上 | in history |
Which nouns take it
上 forms set words, mostly with Sino-Japanese nouns such as 法律, 健康 and 教育. It is not a free rule for every noun, so learn the common combinations. A few native words also take it, such as 行きがかり上, because of how things turned out.
Two kinds of meaning
With a field such as 法律 or 理論, 上 sets the frame for a judgment: 理論上は可能ですが、実際には難しい. With a role or a situation, it gives the circumstances behind something: 仕事の立場上、詳しいことは言えません, because of my position at work, I can't give details.
上 or にとって?
にとって takes the view of a person or group: 私にとって大切だ. 上 does not attach directly to a person such as 私. For your own view, say 私としては.
Same kanji, other patterns
上で and 上は are read うえで and うえは and follow verbs: 考えた上で決める, 約束した上は守る. The suffix 上 in this entry is read じょう and follows nouns.
Register
上 is fairly formal. It is common in news, business and written explanations, and words such as 仕事上 and 健康上 are also everyday.
Examples (4)
- 理論上は可能ですが、実際には難しいです。
It is theoretically possible, but in reality, it is difficult.
Word by Word: Theory-standpoint-on possibility is, but reality-in difficulty is.
Here, 理論上 (りろんじょう) limits the possibility to the realm of theory.
- 彼は健康上の理由で仕事を休んでいる。
He is taking time off work for health-related reasons.
Word by Word: He (topic) health-standpoint-of reason by work (object) resting.
健康上の (けんこうじょうの) modifies 'reason,' specifying that the reason belongs to the domain of health.
- 法律上、この行為は認められていません。
Legally, this act is not permitted.
Word by Word: Law-standpoint, this act (topic) recognized is not.
法律上 (ほうりつじょう) sets the legal perspective for the entire sentence.
- 教育上、子供にその映画を見せるのは良くない。
From an educational standpoint, it is not good to show that movie to children.
Word by Word: Education-standpoint, children to that movie show (nominalizer) good is not.
教育上(きょういくじょう) sets education as the point of view for the judgment that follows.
Common Mistakes
Using it for personal opinions or individuals.
私上、この計画はいいと思います。私としては、この計画はいいと思います。上 does not attach directly to a person such as 私 or to a name. For your own view, use 私としては. To mean because of your position, say 私の立場上.
Attaching it to native Japanese (Wago) words.
体上の理由で休みます。健康上の理由で休みます。上 forms set words, mostly with Sino-Japanese nouns such as 健康 and 法律. 体上 is not one of them, so for health reasons say 健康上の理由.
How It Connects
Learn This First
The grammar pattern '上 (じょう)' is used to limit the scope of a judgment or statement to a specific field (e.g., 'legally', 'historically', 'on the map'). To understand it, learners need to be comfortable with basic noun usage and the conceptual leap of using the kanji for 'above' to mean 'from the perspective of'.
- Kanji basics
Understanding the kanji '上' (up/above) is essential as this pattern uses its abstract meaning of 'from the standpoint of' or 'within the field of'.
Foundations - Noun Modification
The pattern '上' attaches directly to nouns to modify the scope of the following statement, requiring knowledge of how nouns are linked in Japanese.
Level 1
Related Patterns
- 的-ic, -ical
Both are suffixes that modify nouns, but 的 creates an adjective describing a quality, while 上 indicates a specific domain or standpoint.
Level 3 - についてAbout/concerning
について names a topic in general, as in 法律について話す. 上 narrows a statement to one field or circumstance, as in 法律上は問題ない.
Level 3 - にとってFor/to (Perspective)
Both deal with perspective, but にとって is used for the perspective of a person or group, whereas 上 is for a field or system.
Level 3 - 〜上でAfter/upon/in
〜上で is read うえで and follows a verb: た上で means after doing, and る上で means in doing something. The suffix 上 is read じょう even before で, as in データ上で.
Level 3 - 〜上はNow That/since
〜上は is read うえは and means now that, after a verb. After a noun, 上は is read じょうは: 法律上は means as far as the law goes.
Level 3