Right Dislocation
Right Dislocation (Rechtsversetzung) is a conversational strategy where you use a pronoun in the main sentence and then 'spell out' the specific noun at the very end (after the Nachfeld, in the right outer field) to clarify who or what you are talking about.
How It Works
Right Dislocation is a hallmark of informal, spoken German. It serves as a discourse-structuring tool rather than a simple mistake or repair. Unlike an 'afterthought,' which usually has a pause and its own stress, Right Dislocation is typically integrated into the sentence's flow with a lower pitch.
Key Rules:
- Givenness: The listener must be able to tell what you mean, either from the conversation so far or from the situation around you. A referent that is easy to identify in this way can even become a new topic through Right Dislocation.
- Case Matching: The dislocated noun must be in the same case as the resumptive pronoun. If the pronoun is Accusative, the noun must be Accusative.
- Position and Punctuation: The noun appears in the right outer field. This is the space after the final verb of the sentence bracket, and even after the Nachfeld, the slot where other material can follow the bracket. In writing, the dislocated element is set off, usually by a comma and sometimes by a dash or a colon.
- Pronouns: While Left Dislocation usually uses d-pronouns (der, die, das), Right Dislocation frequently uses personal pronouns like er, sie, es, ihn, ihm, etc.
This pattern is very common in daily life but should be avoided in formal writing, where it can appear clumsy or overly colloquial.
Examples (4)
- Wir haben ihn sofort erkannt, euren Hund.
We recognized him right away, your dog.
Word by Word: We have him immediately recognized, your dog.
Here, ihn is accusative, so euren Hund must also be in the accusative case.
- Die ist echt nett, die neue Kollegin.
She is really nice, the new colleague.
Word by Word: The (she) is really nice, the new colleague.
A d-pronoun 'die' is used as the subject, followed by the clarifying noun phrase in the nominative.
- Hast du ihm schon gedankt, dem Onkel?
Have you thanked him yet, the uncle?
Word by Word: Have you him already thanked, the uncle?
The verb 'danken' requires the dative case. Therefore, both the pronoun 'ihm' and the noun 'dem Onkel' are dative.
- Wir haben sie endlich gefunden, die Schlüssel.
We finally found them, the keys.
Word by Word: We have them finally found, the keys.
The plural pronoun 'sie' (accusative) is clarified by 'die Schlüssel' at the end.
Common Mistakes
Using the nominative case for the dislocated noun regardless of the pronoun's case.
Ich habe ihn gesehen, dein Bruder.Ich habe ihn gesehen, deinen Bruder.The noun at the end must match the case of the pronoun. Since 'ihn' is accusative, 'dein Bruder' must become 'deinen Bruder'.
Using Right Dislocation in formal writing.
Sehr geehrte Damen und Herren, wir haben ihn sorgfältig geprüft, den Vertrag.Sehr geehrte Damen und Herren, wir haben den Vertrag sorgfältig geprüft.Right dislocation is a feature of spoken language. In formal letters or essays, it is considered poor style.
How It Connects
Learn This First
To understand right dislocation, you need to be comfortable with basic German sentence structure and personal pronouns. This pattern involves using a pronoun within the main sentence (like 'sie') and then clarifying who or what that pronoun refers to at the very end of the sentence (like 'meine Schwester').
Related Patterns
- Sentence Bracket (Satzklammer)
Right dislocation happens in the right outer field, outside the closing verb bracket and after the Nachfeld.
Level 4 - The Four Cases
Understanding cases is vital because the dislocated noun must match the case of the pronoun in the main clause.
Level 1 - mich/dich/ihnAccusative Pronouns Singular
Accusative pronouns are frequently used as the 'resumptive' elements in right dislocation.
Level 1 - mir/dir/ihmDative Pronouns Singular
Dative pronouns are used when the verb or a preposition in the main clause requires the dative case.
Level 2 - Information Structure
Right dislocation is a specific way to manage the 'topic' (what we are talking about) in a conversation.
Level 5