man (Passiversatz)
Man Instead of Passive
In German, the indefinite pronoun man (one/they/people) is frequently used instead of the passive voice. It keeps the sentence active and personal while focusing on the action rather than a specific individual.
How It Works
Grammar of man. Man is always a subject, and it takes the third person singular verb, like er: man sagt or man kann. It has no other case forms. As an object, use einen (accusative) or einem (dative): Das freut einen. The matching reflexive pronoun is sich, and the matching possessive is sein: Man muss sich um seine Pflanzen kümmern. Keep using man for the same person later in the sentence, rather than switching to er or sie.
From passive to man. The passive subject becomes the accusative object of the man sentence. A dative object stays dative. An impersonal passive has no subject to change, so you only add man:
| Passive | With man |
|---|---|
| Der Brief wird geschrieben. | Man schreibt den Brief. |
| Den Gästen wird geholfen. | Man hilft den Gästen. |
| Hier wird getanzt. | Hier tanzt man. |
The third row shows an impersonal passive turned into a man sentence.
Rules and permissions. With modal verbs, man is the everyday choice: Hier darf man parken sounds more natural in speech than Hier darf geparkt werden, which is more typical of signs and official texts.
Man in a passive. Because man is just a subject pronoun, it can also be the subject of a passive sentence: Dort wird man freundlich empfangen means You are welcomed warmly there. What it cannot do is follow a preposition, so von man does not exist.
Examples (6)
- Man schreibt den Brief.
The letter is being written. (Literally: One writes the letter.)
Word by Word: One writes the letter.
Compare the passive Der Brief wird geschrieben. With man, the letter becomes the accusative object den Brief.
- In diesem Park darf man nicht grillen.
Barbecuing is not allowed in this park.
Word by Word: In this park may one not grill.
With a modal verb, man takes the singular darf. This is more common in speech than darf nicht gegrillt werden.
- Man muss sich morgens waschen.
One must wash oneself in the morning.
Word by Word: One must oneself in the morning wash.
The reflexive pronoun that goes with man is sich.
- Man sollte seine Hausaufgaben machen.
One should do one's homework.
Word by Word: One should one's homework do.
The possessive that goes with man is sein, here seine before a plural noun.
- Wie schreibt man dieses Wort?
How is this word written?
Word by Word: How writes one this word?
English uses a passive here, but German usually asks with man.
- Bei Regen bleibt man am besten zu Hause.
When it rains, it is best to stay at home.
Word by Word: At rain stays one at-the best at home.
Man gives general advice that applies to anyone.
Common Mistakes
Using man after von in a passive
Das Buch wurde von man gelesen.Man hat das Buch gelesen.Man can only be a subject, so it cannot follow a preposition such as von. Make man the subject of an active sentence instead.
Using a plural verb with man
Man sagen, dass es regnet.Man sagt, dass es regnet.Man refers to people in general, but it always takes the third person singular verb.
Switching from man to er or sie
Wenn man müde ist, sollte er schlafen.Wenn man müde ist, sollte man schlafen.Once man is the subject, keep using man for the same general person. Switching to er or sie points to someone specific.
How It Connects
Learn This First
To use 'man' as a passive substitute, you need to understand the impersonal pronoun 'man' itself and the passive voice construction it is intended to replace. Since this construction uses active verb forms to convey a passive meaning, a solid grasp of regular verb conjugation is also essential.
- manImpersonal Pronoun Man
The learner must first understand the basic use of the impersonal pronoun 'man' as 'one' or 'they' before using it as a stylistic alternative to the passive voice.
Level 1 - Process Passive (werden)
To understand 'man' as a passive substitute, the learner must first understand the standard process passive (werden + Partizip II) that it is replacing.
Level 3
Related Patterns
- Passive Of Intransitive Verbs
An impersonal passive like Hier wird getanzt can usually be said as Hier tanzt man.
Level 4 - Modal Verb Construction
Rules and permissions with dürfen or müssen are most often said with man.
Level 1 - Reflexive Pronouns
The reflexive pronoun for man is always sich, as in Man freut sich.
Level 2 - bekommen/kriegen + Past ParticipleRecipient Passive (Bekommen/kriegen)
The bekommen passive is another way to avoid naming the doer. It makes the receiver the subject.
Level 5