教/問/罰/偷

Verbs That Put the Person First

Level 4Sounds Like tau1

In Cantonese, while the verb 畀 (bei2, "to give") often puts the 'thing' first, a specific group of verbs including 教 (gaau3, "to teach"), 問 (man6, "to ask"), 罰 (fat6, "to fine"), and 偷 (tau1, "to steal") follow a strict Person + Thing order.

How It Works

This pattern covers ditransitive verbs (verbs with two objects). While learners often overgeneralize the word order of 畀 (bei2), these four verbs normally put the person first:

  • 教 (gaau3): To teach someone something.
  • 問 (man6): To ask someone something.
  • 罰 (fat6): To fine/punish someone (an amount/penalty).
  • 偷 (tau1): To steal something from someone.

When using 咗 (zo2, perfective) or 過 (gwo3, experiential), the particle attaches to the verb before the person. For example: 罰咗佢五百蚊 (fat6 zo2 keoi5 ng5 baak3 man1) - 'Fined him 500 dollars'.

Note that for 偷 (tau1), the person is the 'source' of the theft: 偷咗我一百蚊 means 'stole a hundred dollars from me'. A phrase such as 偷咗我部相機 can also be heard as simply 'stole my camera', so an amount or other thing that cannot be owned by the person shows the pattern more clearly.

How 畀 is different:
With 畀, the usual spoken order puts the thing first: 畀本書我 (give me the book). With these four verbs the person comes first: 教我游水 (teach me to swim), 問佢幾點 (ask him the time). If the thing is long, move it to the front as a topic: 呢條數學題,你問老師啦 (this maths question, ask the teacher). Both orders belong to the wider family of double-object sentences.

Examples (5)

  1. 佢教過好多人鋼琴。

    She has taught many people the piano.

    Word by Word: She teach [experiential] many people piano.

    The person (many people) comes before the thing (piano). The particle 過 (gwo3) stays with the verb.

  2. 我想問老師一個問題。

    I want to ask the teacher a question.

    Word by Word: I want ask teacher one [classifier] question.

    The person (the teacher) follows the verb 問 (man6) immediately.

  3. 差人罰咗佢五百蚊。

    The police fined him five hundred dollars.

    Word by Word: Police fine [perfective] him five hundred dollars.

    The person being fined (him) comes before the amount (500 dollars).

  4. 佢偷咗我一百蚊。

    He stole a hundred dollars from me.

    Word by Word: He steal [perfective] me one-hundred dollars.

    In Cantonese, this literally means 'He stole me a hundred dollars'. The person (me) is the source, and the amount comes after.

  5. 老師教我哋廣東話。

    The teacher teaches us Cantonese.

    Word by Word: Teacher teach us Cantonese.

    A simple demonstration of the Person (us) + Thing (Cantonese) order.

Common Mistakes

  • Using the 'Thing-First' order (copying the verb 'to give').

    我問一個問題你。
    我問你一個問題。

    While 畀 (bei2) allows the thing to come first, 問 (man6) normally does not. The person usually comes right after the verb.

  • Adding a preposition like 'with' or 'to' before the person.

    我想同你問問題。
    我想問你問題。

    Learners often try to use 同 (tung4, 'with/to') because of English or Mandarin influence. In Cantonese, these verbs take the person directly as an object.

How It Connects

Tap a pattern to see what it builds on and what it leads to.

教/問/罰/偷Level 4Verbs That Put the Person First

Learn This First

To understand verbs like 'teach', 'ask', 'fine', and 'steal' in Cantonese, you need to be familiar with how Cantonese handles sentences with two objects (a person and a thing). You should also be comfortable with basic pronouns and general word order to see how these verbs specifically prioritize the person involved in the action.

Words in This Pattern

教问问罚偷
Sources
  1. Cantonese grammar - Wikipedia
  2. 教 - 廣東話解釋 | 粵典
  3. 問 - 廣東話解釋 | 粵典