is the one to learn if you're moving to Kuala Lumpur or your family is Malaysian. Duolingo has a course for and none for Malay.
Most of the gaps are in the words, especially the ones each language borrowed.
| Where it's official | Malaysia, Brunei and Singapore | Indonesia. About 260 million people speak it, and most of them learned a local language first. |
| Police | , from English | , from Dutch |
| Car | , since means a train | |
| One and a half | 1.5, with a decimal point | 1,5, with a decimal comma |
A shared spelling system arrived in 1972 and removed most of the old spelling gaps, like Malay and Indonesian , which both became c.
A few words look the same but mean something else across the border. In Malay, means free of charge. In Indonesian, means pointless, and the word for free is . In Indonesian, is an insurance policy, not the police.
For Malay or Indonesian, the U.S. Foreign Service Institute (FSI) sets aside 828 class hours, about 36 weeks of full-time study, so its students can use the language at work.
| Study per week | FSI full-time course, Malay or Indonesian (828 hours) |
|---|---|
| 3½ hours | About 4 years 6 months |
| 7 hours | About 2 years 3 months |
| 14 hours | About 1 year 2 months |
| 28 hours | About 7 months |
How long it takes to learn Malay looks at an intensive course at a university in Malaysia, which has six levels of 100 hours each.
| If you want to… | Start with |
|---|---|
| Live in Kuala Lumpur or Penang | Malay |
| Work in Brunei | Malay |
| Spend time in Bali or Jakarta | Indonesian |
| Watch Indonesian films and series | Indonesian |
Malay: Morning Greetings
Perbualan Pagi
Level 1Good morning, how are you?
Good morning, I am well. Thank you.
See you again.
See you again.
Indonesian: Good Morning
Selamat pagi
Level 1Good morning!
Good morning! Do you want some coffee?
Yes, I want some coffee.
Here is the coffee. Please go ahead!
Thank you! See you later.
You're welcome! See you later.
Both lessons open with Selamat pagi, the same good morning in Malay and Indonesian. Poppy, your AI tutor, wrote these two in Bubblegum, a language app that teaches both languages.
Bubblegum
Bubblegum is the best app for serious learners. You learn from text and audio you can mostly understand, which is called comprehensible input.
Tell Poppy, your AI tutor, your level and what you like, and she writes your lessons. If a sentence is hard to follow, ask Poppy to explain it.
With Regenerative Review™, words you save show up again in new lessons, so that you can review words in new contexts without having to use flashcards.
- Malay lessons are set in Malaysia and use the words people say there.
- Malay news comes from Malaysian outlets and Indonesian news from Indonesian ones, rewritten at your level.
- Clear, expressive AI voices read every lesson aloud, with a different voice for each speaker.
- Bubblegum can't make lessons out of a Malay or Indonesian novel you're reading. However, when a sentence stumps you, you can paste it in the chat, and Poppy will explain it.
- Custom lessons cost us money to make, so you need Bubblegum Pro for unlimited custom lessons. Lessons Poppy wrote for other learners are free for everyone to read.
- Regenerative Review™
Mobile
Can Malaysians Understand Indonesian?
Generally, yes, but not every word. In a 1998 test, Malaysian students of Malay found about 30% of the items in Indonesian newspapers odd, unusual or unclear.
Which App Should a Beginner Choose?
If you are serious about learning a language, start with Bubblegum. Poppy, your AI tutor, writes lessons at your level about things you like. More options are in the best apps to learn Malay and the best apps to learn Indonesian.
Is Bubblegum Free?
Yes. Lessons Poppy wrote for other learners are free for everyone to read. Custom lessons cost us money to make, so you need Bubblegum Pro for unlimited custom lessons.
Sources
- Wikipedia, Comparison of Indonesian and Standard Malay (two standardised varieties of Malay, Indonesian official in Indonesia and Malaysian Malay in Brunei, Malaysia and Singapore; generally mutually intelligible, with differences in spelling, grammar, pronunciation, vocabulary and the main source of loanwords; English-influenced and Dutch-influenced romanisation, unified in 1972, when Malay ch and Indonesian tj both became c; Indonesian uses a decimal comma and Malay a decimal point; a 1998 test by Asmah Haji Omar found 30% of the items in Indonesian newspapers odd, unintelligible or unusual to Malaysian Malay linguistics students)
- Wikipedia, Indonesian language (about 80 million first-language and 180 million second-language speakers, 260 million in all, by the 2025 census and Ethnologue)
- Wiktionary, polis (Malay: police, borrowed from English; Indonesian: insurance policy)
- Wiktionary, polisi (Indonesian: police, borrowed from Dutch politie)
- Wiktionary, kereta (Malay: car; Indonesian: train)
- Wiktionary, mobil (Indonesian: car, short for otomobil, from Dutch automobiel)
- Wiktionary, percuma (Malay: free of charge; Indonesian: pointless, wasted)
- Wiktionary, gratis (Indonesian: free, without charge)
- Duolingo: course list (an Indonesian course for English speakers and none for Malay)
- U.S. Department of State, Foreign Language Training (Category II: Indonesian and Malay, about 36 weeks or 828 class hours, for an ILR 3 in speaking and listening)
- Bubblegum